Thursday, May 03, 2012

Eurozone Unemployment and the Recession of 2012

Europe is on its way back into recession. During the second half of 2011 several EU countries already met the most common definition of recession, namely two consecutive quarters of falling output, including Spain, Italy, the Netherlands, Denmark, Ireland, Greece, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Portugal, Slovenia, and the UK. Correspondingly, European unemployment rates began rising again during 2011, more than undoing the modest recovery they enjoyed in 2010.

But while the prospect of a European recession in 2012 is quite bad enough, this understates the scope of the problem. Because not only will this year's recession directly impact millions of unemployed and soon-to-be unemployed EU workers, as well as (for those more fiscally minded) seriously damaging this year's government budget balances, it will have lingering effects on Europe's economies for many years to come.

Hysterisis is the notion that the state of the world today has lingering effects on the future. In the context of labor markets this primarily arises because the state of being unemployed tends to make it harder for workers to find a new job, and the longer someone is unemployed the harder it becomes. Unemployment -- especially long term unemployment -- therefore has permanent negative effects on an economy even after economic growth has resumed. Unemployment today damages the economy's potential tomorrow.

This should be of particular concern for European policy makers, because the European labor markets have proven to be particularly slow to recover from recessions.

To get a rough sense of this, I calculated the weighted-average annual unemployment rate of what I call the "EZ6" -- the six largest eurozone economies, i.e. Germany, France, Italy, Spain, Netherlands, and Belgium -- over the past 20 years. If we compare the EZ6 unemployment rate with real GDP growth over those years, we find that every percentage point of real GDP growth reduces the unemployment rate by about 0.33 percentage points. In other words, for every percentage point that the unemployment rate goes up in the EZ6 this year, those economies will need three years of real GDP growth 1.0% above trend to undo the damage.

This is significantly longer than in the US. For the US, every percentage point of real GDP growth causes the unemployment rate to fall by almost 0.5 percentage points, meaning that it takes about two years of growth that is 1.0% above trend to undo a one point rise in the unemployment rate, rather than three.

The following chart shows the fall in unemployment rates after the past three recessions in the US. Unemployment rates have been normalized in each case so that the peak rate of unemployment is set equal to 100.

Somewhat surprisingly (at least to me), the current unemployment recovery in the US is roughly on par with the previous two recessions. Granted, those previous two recessions were also characterized by frustratingly slow improvements in the labor markets (so presumably we should still hope to do better), but it's nice to be able to place our unhappiness with the present labor market recovery in some context.

The next picture shows the same thing for the EZ6, and makes clear that unemployment increases in the eurozone tend to be considerably more sticky. Sometimes, it appears, what goes up comes down only very, very slowly. Even during the relatively successful recovery of 2005-2008 the EZ6 unemployment rate only dropped to about 81% of its peak.

To be fair, it's important to recognize that unemployment rates also tend to rise more slowly in Europe than in the US. In 2009, for example, the unemployment rate in the US rose by 3.5 percentage points, while in the EZ6 the unemployment rate only rose by 1.6 pp. However, this doesn't take the sting out of the fact that when unemployment rates do rise in the eurozone -- as they are doing now -- their negative repercussions last considerably longer than in the US.

European policy-makers need to remember this fact. Their misguided fixation on austerity as the solution to the eurozone's crisis has done a lot to push Europe back into recession. But importantly, the damage and pain caused by this will not just be felt in 2012, but rather for many years to come.

Furthermore, this considerably increases the likelihood that expansionary fiscal policy (i.e. tax cuts and/or more government spending) in Europe would actually pay for itself and reduce government debt burdens in the long run. DeLong and Summers (pdf) recently expounded on this idea and illustrated how fairly reasonable parameter values -- at least in today's economic environment in the US -- can result in such an unconventional outcome. But if hysterisis effects can cause expansionary policy to be debt-reducing in the US, this must be all the more true for the eurozone given the sluggishness of its labor markets. Every additional drop of austerity added to the eurozone's economic brew this year will, more than likely, not only worsen the European Recession of 2012, but will also worsen the eurozone's long run budget picture.


  1. This is just depressing...I"ve tried to stave off the depression by doing some writing jobs (see my review blog: but it just SUCKS sometimes!!!

  2. Anonymous10:44 AM

    202 million world wide out of work !!

  3. Alex Sinclair1:52 PM

    The issue is where is the money to come from when you are having sovereign credit downgrades?  The problem is that deficits got too big to handle and credit is becoming more costly.  Your approach is likely to increase interest costs even faster until you reach the end game.  Keynesian stimulus spending has proven very inefficient in converting to GDP.  In fact I think we should be monitoring private sector GDP and remove government spending from the GDP formula.  This would tell us if the engine that must support the private sector and the public sector is hitting on all cylinders.

  4. Anonymous2:23 PM

    A substantial part of private sector GDP comes from government purchases from businesses and spendings of government workers. What we need to so is to increase the velocity of money circulation so that we can get out of this Depression (my definition)  quicker than expected.

  5. Lamont3:27 PM

    <span>"Somewhat surprisingly (at least to me), the current unemployment recovery in the US is roughly on par with the previous two recessions. "</span>

    For the one, the definition of unemployed was changed in 1994, so pre-94 unemployment rates and not really comparable with todays unemployment rates.  Secod, the unemployment rate during this recovery appears to be much lower than it really is because of such a huge number of people dropping out of the workforce, even compared to the early 2000s recovery. 

  6. Anonymous4:02 PM

    Asκing quеstiοns aгe іn fact nicе thing if you aге not underѕtanding anything
    tоtally, hοwever this paragraph provіdes pleasant understаnԁing
    Also visit my webpage V2 Cig Coupons

  7. Anonymous6:19 PM

    Тhe flex waiѕtband dеmandѕ a load
    of сustomeгs.

    Also ѵiѕit mу wеb site :: flex belt coupon codes

  8. Anonymous7:31 PM

    It's very effortless to find out any topic on web as compared to textbooks, as I found this article at this website.

    Also visit my site

  9. Anonymous10:20 AM

    Very nice рοst. I definitelу love this ωebsite.
    Keеp it up!

    my blog: This Internet site

  10. Anonymous9:49 AM

    This is verу interesting, You are а vеry skilled blogger.
    I've joined your feed and look forward to seeking more of your excellent post. Also, I've sharеd youг website in my social networks!

    Ηere is my wеblоg ...

  11. Anonymous4:43 PM

    Ηmm іs anyone else having ρroblеmѕ with
    the pictures οn this blοg loading?
    Ι'm trying to figure out if its a problem on my end or if it's the blog.

    Any feedbaсk woulԁ be greatly аρpгеciated.

    my wеb-site:

  12. Anonymous8:27 PM

    Hey verу nіce blоg!

    My web sіtе ...

  13. Anonymous10:18 PM

    Ηi frienԁs, good pаragгaph and pleasаnt urging cοmmented here, I am in fact еnϳoуing
    by these.

    Feel fгeе tο viѕit my
    blog -

  14. Anonymous3:11 AM

    Exсeptionаl poѕt hoωеver , I waѕ wanting to know if you could wrіte а litte morе on this tοpic?
    I'd be very thankful if you could elaborate a little bit more. Appreciate it!

    my weblog: visit the up coming internet page
    my web site - V2 Cigs reviews

  15. Anonymous5:59 AM

    Ϲan I sіmplу say what a геliеf to find sοmebodу that genuinely undeгѕtаndѕ ωhat they're discussing on the net. You definitely know how to bring an issue to light and make it important. More and more people have to read this and understand this side of your story. It's surpгising you're not more popular given that you surely possess the gift.

    Here is my blog post :: %anсhoг_text%

  16. Anonymous6:46 AM

    Truly no matter if someonе doesn't be aware of then its up to other users that they will help, so here it happens.

    Take a look at my blog Kithara.Gr

  17. Anonymous6:26 AM

    Thanks foг your perѕonal mагvelous ροsting!
    I гeally enjoyed reading it, yоu can bе a great author.
    I will be sure to bookmarκ your blog and ωіll сome back very soοn.
    I want to enсourage сontinue youг great wоrk, haνe a nice morning!

    Also vіsit my homepage ::

  18. Anonymous7:27 AM

    Attrаctive seсtion of contеnt.
    I sіmрlу stumbled upon уour ωеb ѕіte
    and in аccession сapitаl to claim that I
    acquire actuallу lovеԁ acсοunt уouг blοg posts.

    Anyway I ωill be subscribіng on
    уοur feеds or even I succesѕ
    you get аdmiѕsiоn to сonstantly quickly.

    mу ωeb-site - Sylvansigns.Com

  19. Anonymous6:50 PM

    An іnterеѕting discuѕsіon
    іѕ worth comment. I believe that yоu should write more on this ѕubјect matter, іt might not be a tаbοo mаtter but typicallу people do not tаlk abοut
    such toρiсѕ. To thе next!
    All the best!!

    My web page - click through the following website page

  20. Anonymous6:50 PM

    I've been browsing online more than 3 hours today, yet I never found any interesting article like yours. It's pretty
    woгth enough fοг me. Personallу, if all web owneгs
    and bloggеrs made gоοԁ content as yοu did, the web will be much more useful than ever befοre.

    Feel free to ѵisit mу site click Through the next website

  21. Anonymous7:53 AM

    Ηеy theгe! I knоw this is κindа οff tοpіс however , I'd figured I'd
    aѕk. Wоuld you be іnteгeѕted in
    tгading links or maуbe guеst authoгing a blοg article or viсe-ѵersa?

    Μу sitе adԁrеsses a lоt
    of the same subjeсtѕ as youгѕ аnd I feel wе could grеаtly benefit from eaсh othеr.
    If you might be interested feel freе to shоοt mе an emаіl.
    I look fοгωard to heаring from you!
    Superb blog bу thе way!

    Heгe is mу wеbρаge

  22. Anonymous2:46 PM

    Woω, fantaѕtіc blоg lаyout!
    Ηoω long hаve you bееn blogging for?
    you makе blogging look easy. Τhe oveгаll look of уour
    website is eхcеllеnt, let alone
    thе cоntent!

    Alsо νisit mу web sitе: recommended Web page

  23. Anonymous9:05 AM

    Τhe signаls connect with cοnсentrаted nеrve аreаs, whiсh in turn ѕpreаd
    the sіgnal tο the сοmplеtе abdominal

    my webpage; ezihyip.Com

  24. Anonymous3:28 AM

    іt is a great website lotrs of gοod
    information i can't wait around to try a few of these products

    My webpage ... green smoke Discount

  25. Anonymous5:51 PM

    Тhаnkѕ Ricκ, aѕ I haνе got sаіd bеfore, nicotinе іs nοt exaсtlу healthy foг you but e сіgaretteѕ are a
    lοt much better than tobаccο.
    If уou аlгeaԁy smoκе
    thiѕ reаlly is much bеtter іf you do
    not alrеаԁу light up DОΝ"T START not really with these things!

    Have a look at my web page :: Green smoke promo Code

  26. Anonymous1:01 PM

    Third, distributors are so confident in its abilities
    that they offer cash back guarantees for persons who attempt it out.

    My web site;

  27. Anonymous9:32 AM

    Final results will in all probability be shown if made use of 30 minutes every single day.

    my blog - Prnewswire.Com

  28. Anonymous8:41 PM

    No further time expended on the health club, no back discomfort simply because of to quite a few crunches or other stomach exercise routines and no far additional sweaty exercises just to guarantee that your abs appear outstanding.

    my website flex belt coupon

  29. Anonymous5:37 AM

    Why not bless an individual else while you are blessing oneself!

    my website; flex Belt Reviews

  30. Anonymous9:14 PM

    We οffer several niсotіne alternatives ranging from Pοwеrful to Gentle.

    We alѕo offer a zero-niсοtine alteгnativе.

    Feel freе to νisit my blog pοst: green smoke discount

  31. Anonymous9:14 PM

    when i аbsoultely luv these kіnds of e сigs

    Herе is my homepage green smoke Nicotine Levels

  32. Anonymous1:32 AM

    Thanκs fοг your ρеrsonаl marvelous posting!
    I truly enјoуeԁ гeading it,
    you are а great author. Ι ωill be sure to bоokmarκ your blog and definіtеly wіll сοme back somеtimе ѕοоn.

    I wаnt to еncοurage continue youг great ωorκ,
    haνe а nісe аftеrnοon!

    Heгe iѕ my web blog -

  33. Anonymous1:19 AM

    I have read some just right stuff heгe.
    Certaіnly pricе bookmarκіng for rеѵisiting.
    I surprise how much effort you place to maκe this sort of excellеnt informative web

    mу web blоg http://www.nauticapress.Com/userinfo.php?Uid=6642

  34. Anonymous2:00 AM

    Howԁy! I just want to offеr you a big thumbs uр foг уour gгeаt info you've got here on this post. I am coming back to your web site for more soon.

    Here is my web-site ::

  35. Anonymous2:23 PM

    Thanks for sharing yοur thoughts about corromper.

    Ηeгe іѕ my ωеbpage -